Dave Scott’s Guide to Swimming Form – Road ID posterous
Posted on Feb 23, 2011 under fitness, Raves | Comments are offDave Scott’s Guide to Swimming Form – Road ID posterous.
Great tips – stuff to keep in mind for sure!
Archives for fitness category
Dave Scott’s Guide to Swimming Form – Road ID posterous.
Great tips – stuff to keep in mind for sure!
Great article. Definitely stuff in here I need to work on. Need to get Kim to video tape me running so I can do some analysis.
Nytro has some great posts on their blog. The newest is on pacing, but make sure to check the sidebar for other great posts.
If you’ve known me for a while, you probably know that I used to be a very active technical scuba diver and instructor. I’d dive deep, and long, in dark waters where the shoreline wasn’t visible and hadn’t been for some time, this includes night dives and ice dives. It’s great experience that I bring to my triathlon training. Unlike so many triathletes, I have no fear of swimming where I can’t see the bottom, or even, for that matter, the shoreline.
A lot of triathlon training sites talk about what to do when you get to the site and are preparing for the swim: Things like stretching, doing some warm-up lengths, looking around at landmarks so that you can sight while you’re swimming, landmarking your bike in the holding pen, etc. All good stuff to be sure. But something I haven’t yet seen anywhere, is a discussion of “Mammalian diving reflex”.
Quoted from wikipedia, highlights added by me:
The mammalian diving reflex optimizes respiration which allows mammals to stay underwater for a long time. It is exhibited strongly in aquatic mammals (seals, otters, dolphins, etc.), but exists in a weaker version in other mammals, including humans… Every animal’s diving reflex is triggered specifically by cold water contacting the face β water that is warmer than 21 Β°C (70 Β°F) does not cause the reflex, and neither does submersion of body parts other than the face. Also, the reflex is always exhibited more dramatically, and thus can grant longer survival, in young individuals.
Upon initiation of the reflex, three changes happen to the body, in this order:
1 Bradycardia is the first response to submersion. Immediately upon facial contact with cold water, the human heart rate slows down ten to twenty-five percent… Slowing the heart rate lessens the need for bloodstream oxygen, leaving more to be used by other organs.
2 Next, peripheral vasoconstriction sets in… Toes and fingers close off first, then hands and feet, and ultimately arms and legs stop allowing blood circulation, leaving more blood for use by the heart and brain. Human musculature accounts for only 12% of the body’s total oxygen storage, and the body’s muscles tend to suffer cramping during this phase. Aquatic mammals have as much as 25 to 30% of their oxygen storage in muscle, and thus they can keep working long after capillary blood supply is stopped.
:
:When the face is submerged, receptors that are sensitive to cold within the nasal cavity and other areas of the face supplied by cranial nerve V (trigeminal) relay the information to the brain and then innervate cranial nerve X, which is part of the autonomic nervous system. This causes bradycardia and peripheral vasoconstriction. Blood is removed from the limbs and all organs but the heart and the brain, creating a heart-brain circuit and allowing the mammal to conserve oxygen.
In humans, the mammalian diving reflex is not induced when limbs are introduced to cold water. Mild bradycardia is caused by subjects holding their breath without submerging the face within water. When breathing with face submerged this causes a diving reflex which increases proportionally to decreasing water temperature. Activating the diving reflex with cold water can be used to treat supraventricular tachycardia. However the greatest bradycardia effect is induced when the subject is holding breath with face submerged.
In the swim leg of the race, you may experience diving reflex as the feeling of the inability to breathe, gasping for air, the closing of the throat, cramping and panic. Clearly something you want to avoid π Fortunately, you can prepare yourself for the shock and teach your body to handle it in a manageable way.
When we’re scuba diving in very cold water, we’ll submerse our faces (with our masks off) and force ourselves to breathe through the regulator or a snorkel to get past the bradycardia and autonomic response to hold your breath or breathe quickly and shallowly in response to the cold and dive reflex. This body training will last 30-60 minutes after the “familiarization training” and greatly reduce your body’s negative reactions to the cold water. In much the same way, you should spend a few minutes pre-swim preparing your body for the shock of the water temperature.
Start by standing at a comfortable depth, bend over and with your goggles off put your face in the water and relax. Breathe out with slowly with your face submerged and turn your head as though you’re free-style breathing to inhale. Try to breathe deep and steadily, using your diaphragm, pulling air deep into your belly. Continue breathing in this position until you feel calm and relaxed in your breathing and comfortably accustomed to the cold shock of the water and air.
By acclimatizing yourself to the cold water on your face (including around your eyes), you’ll be much less likely to suffer negative reactions of mammalian dive reflex during the race, especially if you somehow loose your mask during the swim.
Yesterday my ebay win for a set of bullhorn and aerobars arrived at the house. Super excited it was all I could do to finish my work day before running off to tinker with my bike. A few well placed phone calls had located a great deal on some bar-end shifters for the aerobars, amazingly, at a little bike shop just around the corner from my house called HoopDriver.
Immediately after I was done work I walked a dog up to the store, grabbed some handlebar tape, the bar-end shifters and some handlebar shims (the bullhorns are 26mm, but my stem is a 30.5mm), and zipped home to install. I’ve done basic bike maintenance before, but never anything like removing Shimano Tiagra brifters and recabling deraileurs. With a little advice from my friend Paul, it went swimmingly and in seemingly no time my bike was refit with new bars, break levers, and bar-end shifters on the aerobars. Super exciting! I didn’t bother with the bar tape yet, but will probably do that tonight. Not really so important as I wanted this configuration for spinning in the trainer and don’t want to be on my hands but rather down on the aerobars building stamina and tweaking bike fit in that position.
This morning I took the new setup for a 75 minute test spin. My coach had only planned for a 60 minute zone 2 spin for me, but the aero setup felt so good that I was happy to sit in it and finish watching 2006 Ironman Kona for the extra 15 minutes. With luck, I still hope to be picked as RacerMate‘s Desperate Athlete and win a computrainer and year’s training program, but for now, I make do with a borrowed Cyclops liquid trainer and old tv shows. Hey! It passes the time and does the job, right? π
Thursdays are brick days, cycle for a while, then run to work. Running today, in the -12C and snow from the last 36 hours was challenging. I ran in my cycling rain pants, pulled out my yaktrax, and replaced my new orthotics with my older ones. (My new orthotics have been wrecking my feet and, while I think they’re better now, my feet are still pretty destroyed and so letting them heal seemed like a good idea.) I also wore my neoprene face mask to start the run. Outside, waiting for my gps to sync up, I was cool, but far from cold, so I felt that I’d dressed appropriately for the weather.
It’s funny, I caught myself with an interesting thought form this morning. While I was walking the dogs after by ride/before my run, as I was dressing to take them out, I found myself thinking: “Brr! Looks cold out there, guess I’ll judge how warm I need to dress for my run, while I walk the dogs.” and then I caught myself and laughed a bit. I think many would go outside to see if it’s too cold to run, I just wanted to know how warm to dress. Awesome! π
Perceived level of effort (confirmed with my HRM) this morning was significantly higher than normal. I was trying to keep mid zone 3 for the 5.7k long route to work and was generally successful I think. My legs felt like lead the whole way in, but having just watched Kona, and seeing blind athletes and dual leg amputees complete an IM, I wasn’t about to let 5.7k and some snow shut me down! I’m sure that part of my lead feet was the extra weight of the yaktrax and the snow/ice bound up in them, but such is life. We’ll just call this hyper-gravity running π Some use ankle weights, I come by it more… naturally π
Which brings me to “Annoying Pedestrians”: ok folks, I know it snowed and that there’s snow and slush on the sidewalks, but nowhere on my entire run in, was the sidewalk only cleared 1-person wide. Yet, frequently I found myself having to dodge around people, (or later in the run yell at them to move aside) because they were shuffling zombie-like down the middle of the cleared path. Is it so hard to share?! Come on! Really?! Sheesh!
Something great from the Kona show this morning. 1st 2 letters of IMpossible are “I” “M”: IronMan. Impossible? Ironman: Possible! Love it!
Ok… done ranting and raving now. Coffee time. Y’all have a good day. I’m pretty pumped for a good one myself. Tonight, a 8k run home. Booya!
I’ve often wondered about what people do on Ironman or Ultra races when “nature calls”.
Seems I’m not the only person concerned with that.
LavaMagazine has a nice writeup on Racing GI upset, Fiber and how to help “manage” π
I recently joined the Toronto Triathlon Club, tonight they held an openwater swim techniques class that I attended, and I’m so glad that I did.
The class started with some slideware that was really nothing new to me (set measurable goals, be disciplined, etc.), but in the pool I learned so much!
We covered sighting, drafting both directly behind and beside another swimmer, techniques for turning around buoys and did a bunch of drills to get experience swimming in a pack in the water and specifically around buoys.
Sighting, not that hard: every now and then, while maintaining your swim cadence, look forward (or around), by lifting your eyes (but not your nose) out of the water. I.e. stay down, you’re not dog paddling or breast-stroking, you’re continuing to swim freestyle/crawl, and just moving your head slightly differently.
Drafting: it works! It really works! In the foot wash is perhaps a little better than beside, but comes with the risks of getting a foot in the face and the annoyance of seeing little but bubbles. Drafting to the side takes more focus as you need to synchronize your stroke with the leader and get right into their side-wake, but also works pretty effectively.
Turning around buoys: generally something you want to do quickly, as they get choked up with other swimmers. Stay in tight, sprint around the turn. Turn either by pulling hard with one of your arms (I found the outside arm easier, but not everyone had the same experience), or by flipping quickly to back stroke for a beat and then back to freestyle. The latter method really worked well for me. I found I could drive around a buoy quickly, regardless of whether there were other people there or not.
The group swim stuff we did was probably the most useful to me though. Having never swam in a racing group before (around corners) it was interesting to see how physical and assertive you have to be to not completely loose your place, and time, cornering around the buoys. Think full-contact swimming or WWE meets swimming and you’re not far off. I think if the 1st time I’d experienced that were in a race or even in open water, I’d have been taken by such surprise that I would have stalled completely. By the end of today’s session I definitely had the right level of “assertiveness” going around the buoys. π
Tired now. 1.5 hrs on the bike this morning, jobs around the house during the day and 4 hrs swim techniques in the evening. Bedtime π
Realized this morning while I was showering, post swim, that I’m really hooked on data and using it effectively to inform and guide my training toward Ironman Muskoka this fall.
At times I feel a bit like a cyborg, but I really think that the data-driven results don’t lie. Here’s the current level of my cyborg-y-ness:
A few words about each of these tools and the data they provide me:
Bodybugg
The bodybugg, through a bunch of different sensors, tells you how many calories you’re actually burning while sleeping, awake, exercising, watching TV, what have you. They claim it’s 95% accurate, and to me, 95% is way better than generalized estimates based on METS or some other random equation. Unfortunately the bodybugg doesn’t work in the water (and isn’t waterproof) so it’s off and in the locker when I’m swimming.
I started with the bodybugg and the wrist receiver and “upgraded” to the bodybuggSP when it came out. The SP is still pretty rough around the edges on my Android phone, but they’re working on it. Had I known I’d be paying to beta test their software, I’d have probably waited. There are still nagging issues with the trip functions of the software on Android that are pretty annoying.
The great thing about the bodybugg is that, because you know what you’re burning, you can eat appropriately. Making sure you consume the right amount of nutrition to keep the machine functioning efficiently. More on nutrition in a minute.
Timex Global Trainer
Probably the biggest watch on the planet, the Global Trainer is an ANT+ compatible HRM, bicycle computer, and GPS device. I really like it, it does a great job, of tracking my heart-rate, speed, distance and on the bike cadence (and speed while in the trainer).
Recently I went for VO2max testing with Ian at ImFit.ca, so now I can really dial in my training to target my aerobic capacity and work at moving my anerobic base. Good stuff.
If I had an ANT+ powermeter, the Global Trainer would integrate with that too and provide even more (super useful) data to help guide my training. I’m not sure if Computrainers are ANT+ compatible, but if they were this would be ΓΌber! π No, I don’t currently own a computrainer, but Racermate is having a contest at the moment, so if I’m really lucky, I may win one combined with a year’s training!
The computrainers provide even more data that I’d love to sink my teeth into, like pedal stroke analysis, power output and a whole slew of others. All that combined with virtual-reality interactive cycling that would certainly make the miles pass by faster.
Sportcount
When I’m swimming I probably have the least tech helping me out and gathering data. Currently I just have a (blue) sportcount lap counter. This gives me average, fastest, slowest and total swim times and that’s about it. It’s a useful tool because after the 40th or so lap, I generally lose count. That, and counting laps tends to pull me away from focusing on technique or just zoning out to the swim. So, while not providing a lot of data, the sportcount is still super useful.
Now, Finis have released the Swimsense, which looks pretty amazing! Unfortunately with all the other training and gear expenses (read: desires for a time-trial bike), a swimsense just isn’t in the budget. Perhaps Finis would loan me one for a blog review (ahem! nudge, nudge).
TrainingPeaks.com
TrainingPeaks seems to be pretty much the de facto online tool for endurance athletes. It’s feature rich with a lot of graphs and analytics for monitoring your training, stress levels, diet, weight, nutrition over time. I generally like the site now that I’m getting used to it. It’s cool that my Timex Global Trainer interfaces directly with the site and that my coach can directly see my workouts, plan sessions for me, see my nutrition info, etc. Pretty slick.
My biggest complaint with trainingpeaks.com is that it’s built in flash. Flash was probably a great choice 5-8 years ago before html5, ajax, javascript and modern browsers, but now flash just makes websites hostile and heavy weight. Hopefully someday they fix this, but for now, I’ve grown used to the odd quirks and slow load times.
I track my workouts, my bodybugg daily data, and nutrition on trainingpeaks.com. So, onto Nutrition:
Those of you who know me, know that in Aug of 2009 I was a “pretty big guy”β’. I tipped the scale at just over 250lbs and, while I considered myself pretty fit (for a guy my size) I was a long way from being a healthy weight. My wife and I did the Dr. Bernstein diet for 4 months and I lost 85lbs. More important than the weightloss, I discovered things about my diet and how I related to food and most importantly, how my body reacts to specific foods. I now maintain a diet that I strictly monitor. I closely track sodium, and the 3 macronutrients (fat, carb, and protein). My daily nutrition plan isn’t really set in stone, but does follow some pretty hard guidelines, as follows:
That’s about it, I’m pretty anal about it, but it gives me a lot of room to play too. I definitely don’t feel constrained by it and eating in this plan keeps my energy levels up, my digestive system happy, and my bloat down.
Have to say, I’m pretty happy with my feedback system. There are some places I’d love to improve it if I had the funds, but I definitely feel armed with more than ample data to guide me strongly forward to Ironman Muskoka.
Oh… and just because I have to… I am Iron..Man… π
In case you can’t tell, I’m pretty excited about my swim this morning.
I’d hit the pool planning on just a long, easy effort. 4k, no drills other than watching technique. 1.5 hrs.. Did tempo drills on Wednesday and am going for VO2max testing with Ian MacLean on Sunday morning, so I figured a nice leisurely swim before my Saturday rest day would be a good way to end the week.
It was not to be the case, but I couldn’t be happier.
You see, on Wednesday, when I was doing my tempo drills, I had a few lengths (short short intervals) where, I felt like I was just flying through the water. That as fast as my arms and body could move, that’s how fast I’d go. I just getting faster, and faster and faster. Until I slammed into the end of the pool, lost the rhythm and had to start over again. (Have I mentioned how much I’m looking forward to swimming outside?!). Not really knowing what had happened, or what I was doing differently, I just accepted the fluke, marvelled at it a bit, and continued swimming.
Well, today.. about 1km into my swim, I think I figured out what was going on on Wednesday and managed to string it together. OMG! I was flying! I discovered that I was, in essence, doing the equivalent of a “heel strike” in the water. I have had a deadspot in my stroke during the recovery, where I was just coasting through the water, essentially negating any forward momentum I’d built up with my last stroke. This morning on figuring this out, I started working on making my stroke consistently paced throughout the entire stroke/recovery/stroke/recovery cycle and the difference was intense. My speed jumped almost 2x: swimmers who I’d normally outpace in 3/4 of a lap, I was catching in less than a length (< 18m).
I even know how I got to the "in water heel strike" problem. You may recall me touting Total Immersion swimming technique. It’s great! Very efficient and there’s a lot of youtube videos and stuff on their website to help you sort out your technique. One of the drills is basically working the recovery, extension and rotation aspects of the technique. I think I latched onto that drill to hard and never strung each side of the drill gracefully together (until Wednesday and now today). Hurray!
This discovery is also, a little (but not much really) bitter-sweet. I’m already, typically, the fastest person in the fast lane (and I’m not fast), so when there are 3 or more swimmers sharing a lane, I’m constantly in someone’s toes. If they don’t let me pass and the end of the length, I either have to move through my stroke very slowly (which re-enforces the poor technique I’m trying to fix), change to a breast stroke (sure it’s exercise, but not particularly useful for my training meh) or just wait for them to get a length ahead of me so that I can catch them again and repeat. (Have I mentioned how much I’m looking forward to swimming outside?!).
Also, the lack of the “coast” section of the stroke raised my perceived effort a bit, makes sense I guess: no little micro rest built into each stroke. So I’ll have a new effort hurdle to break-down. No problem, kinda fun actually.
I hopped out of the pool after 2km (40 minutes, a lot spent waiting), while I was still pretty fresh and had been working my new-found technique pretty consistently for several lengths. I wanted to stop before I got fatigued so that my body would hopefully develop some good patterning from the discovery.
I may head back to the pool later today to do another few 2-4km just to better ingrain my new discovery. I’m so psyched! Can I balance this, with my need for some downtime prior to Sunday’s testing. I guess we’ll see… I guess we’ll see. π
I’m starting to catalog my scuba gear that I’m going to sell off and hope that it raises enough money to buy a nice time-trial bike and still have some left over for paying down other debt, maybe taking a vacation with my honey, and/or paying for some house renos.
While I’d dearly love that Argon-18, I’m facing reality that it’s highly unlikely that I’ll be able to afford it and that retrofitting my Trek 1.5 is likely the “way to go”.
Desired Upgrades
So roughly in order (though cheaper things like seatpost and saddle will probably happen out of order):
Now, that all said, I’m not beyond charity – in any of the forms of gift, loan or amazing deal – on any of this stuff. Wanna pay it forward? I’m your man π I promise to do the same for someone else someday. π